Military Disability Nexus

Clinician-led expert medical opinions for VA disability claims

1151 Claims

Understanding 1151 Claims: When VA Medical Care Goes Wrong

Editorial Team

October 1, 2025

8 min read

Understanding 1151 Claims: When VA Medical Care Goes Wrong

What is a 1151 Claim?

A 1151 claim, filed under 38 U.S.C. § 1151, allows veterans to seek compensation when they are injured or their condition is worsened due to VA medical care, treatment, or hospitalization.

When to Consider a 1151 Claim

Surgical Errors: Complications from VA surgeries due to negligence
Medication Mistakes: Wrong medications or dosages causing harm
Hospital-Acquired Infections: Infections due to unsanitary conditions
Misdiagnosis: Delayed or incorrect diagnosis leading to worsening
Treatment Delays: Unreasonable delays causing deterioration

Key Differences from Regular Claims

Unlike standard VA disability claims, 1151 claims require proving:

VA negligence or deviation from medical standards
Direct causation between VA care and your injury
Additional disability beyond your original condition

Evidence Requirements

Strong 1151 claims typically include:

Complete VA medical records
Independent medical expert opinions
Documentation of the standard of care
Proof of additional disability or worsening

Why Expert Medical Opinion Matters

1151 claims have a higher burden of proof than regular VA claims. Expert medical analysis is crucial to establish that the VA deviated from accepted medical standards and directly caused your injury or worsening condition.

Need help with your VA claim?

Get expert guidance and documentation from our licensed clinicians

Get Free Consultation

Content Standards

Written By

Military Disability Nexus Editorial Team

Educational Guidance and Evidence Research

View editorial standards

Reviewed For Clinical Accuracy

Military Disability Nexus Clinical Review Team

Clinical Integrity and Accuracy Review

View medical review policy

Originally published October 1, 2025 • Last updated May 3, 2026

#1151 claim#VA malpractice#medical negligence

Related Insights

What Is a 38 U.S.C. § 1151 Claim? When VA Healthcare Causes Additional Disability

A 38 U.S.C. § 1151 claim is a VA disability benefits claim that compensates veterans who suffered additional disability caused by VA hospital care, medical treatment, surgical treatment, or examination. Unlike standard service connection, it does not require a link to military service. The veteran must prove VA care caused the injury and that VA was at fault or the outcome was not reasonably foreseeable. If granted, benefits are paid as if the disability were service-connected.

The VA Medication Rule Was Rescinded: What Ingram v. Collins Means for Your Rating

In February 2026 the VA published a rule that would have rated your disability based on how you function on your medication, then rescinded it days later. The prior standard is back. And here's what trips up most veterans: Ingram v. Collins was never rescinded, only the rule that tried to override it was. That's why your C&P exam still asks about your functioning without medication. This is where things actually stand, and what the evidence needs to show to capture your true severity.

The Proposed VA Sleep Apnea Rating Change: What It Means for Your 50%

The VA has proposed changing how it rates sleep apnea, and the change would end the automatic 50% rating that veterans now get for using a CPAP. The proposal is not final, there is no start date, and current ratings would be protected. But if you have sleep apnea and are not yet service-connected, this is a “file while the current rules are in effect” moment. Here is what would change, what is still the same, and what to do now.

About this article. This post is general educational and medical information published by the Military Disability Nexus clinical team. It is not legal advice, not individualized medical advice, and not a substitute for a personal evaluation by a licensed clinician or a consultation with an accredited representative. Reading it does not create a doctor-patient or attorney-client relationship. VA law and rating criteria change; some details may not reflect the most recent updates, and every claim is decided by the VA on its own facts – no outcome is promised or guaranteed. Military Disability Nexus is an independent medical-evidence provider and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or acting on behalf of the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs or any government agency. Free claims assistance is available from VA-accredited Veterans Service Organizations and county Veterans Service Officers; you can verify any representative's accreditation through the VA Office of General Counsel.